Yet Again, the Media’s Covid Narrative Doesn’t Add Up

Source: Mises Institute.

“If one were to go only on what one reads or sees in the media, one would think it’s the spring of 2020 all over again. The headlines are filled with stories of overcrowded hospitals, overwhelmed medical personnel, and predictions of people dying in parking lots waiting for medical care. The news articles generally quote a staffer of some kind at various hospitals and then leave it at that.

“It’s difficult to know what to make of these stories.”

DeSantis sets plan for Regeneron monoclonal antibodies to fight COVID-19

Source: Local 10 News in South Florida.

This story makes perfect sense. Assuming there is evidence that recent variants of the Covid virus (Delta, Delta Plus, Lambda) are evading acquired immunity, pushing therapeutics is the right public-health response.

I’m pretty sure most Americans thought the Covid vaccines would eradicate the virus. Introducing non-vaccine pharmaceuticals to combat Covid might seem like a signal of vaccine failure, but I think it should have been part of public-health policy from the beginning.

Sterilizing Immunity and COVID-19 Vaccines

Source: Verywell.

I never heard the term sterilizing immunity until just the other day, but the concept was deeply embedded in my own assumptions. I assumed that all immunity is “sterilizing,” meaning that disease and infection are both prevented. It turns out that immunity can also be “non-sterilizing,” meaning that while disease is prevented infection is not.

I find the distinction useful for making sense of media reports on Covid-19 vaccines. For example, when a journalist talks about the “efficacy” of a vaccine you can usually interpret that as referring to its sterilizing effect. In fact, effective immunity — also called practical immunity — is synonymous with non-sterilizing immunity.

The Covid-19 vaccines confer non-sterilizing immunity. That’s much simpler to understand than the idea that no vaccine is perfect.

‘New science is worrisome’: CDC recommends wearing masks indoors, again. What that means for vaccinated Americans.

Source: USA Today.

I take this story to be a sign that the risk of Antibody-Dependent Enhancement (ADE) of SARS-COV-2 infection is now officially recognized.

ADE is a phenomenon in which vaccinated people become more prone to harmful effects of new virus variants such that they are more likely to be harmed than unvaccinated people. ADE was not found to occur in the clinical trials for the current Covid vaccines prior to their public rollout, but the potential was well established.

If public health officials have solid evidence of ADE, how would they message it? Surely not by telling the vaccinated they face new Covid dangers they did not expect.